Score the demonstrated arrangement, not the sales presentation. Use whole-number scores and document the evidence supporting every rating.
| Raw score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 0 | No usable evidence, or demonstrated inability to meet the criterion |
| 1 | Weak; predominantly an assertion or material unresolved operational deficiency |
| 2 | Some credible capability, but not all requirements for 3 are met |
| 3 | Meets every agreed minimum requirement for the criterion |
| 4 | Meets 3 and demonstrates substantial, verified advantages, but not every requirement for 5 |
| 5 | Meets every predeclared stretch requirement with suitable verification |
What evidence limits should apply?
Apply an evidence ceiling to prevent documentation quality from being confused with operational proof.
| Evidence status | Definition | Maximum score |
|---|---|---|
| U — Unavailable | Missing, unusable, stale or materially mismatched evidence | 0 |
| A — Assertion | Marketing statement, untested demonstration or unsupported supplier attestation | 1 |
| D — Documented | Relevant procedures, commitments and supporting records reviewed, but not independently tested | 3 |
| V — Verified | Relevant primary records independently checked, buyer-tested performance, or an executed obligation verified for the claim being scored | 5 |
An executed contract can verify an obligation; it does not verify future delivery performance. A software demonstration can verify a feature; it does not establish that every dispensing partner supplies complete events.
For each criterion:
Final criterion score = lower of raw capability score and evidence ceiling
Weighted points = criterion weight × final criterion score ÷ 5
Total selection score = sum of weighted points
Also report evidence coverage: the total weight of criteria supported at D or V level. Use it as disclosure, not as a second multiplier that double-penalises missing evidence.
What decision follows from the result?
| Result | Recommended decision |
|---|---|
| Any gate FAIL | Exclude the proposed arrangement until the underlying issue is remedied and re-reviewed. |
| Any gate HOLD | Keep unranked. Resolve the question before a live pilot or supply commitment. |
| All gates pass; 80–100; every criterion at least 3 | Eligible for final award review, subject to required contracts, implementation acceptance and specialist sign-off. |
| All gates pass; 70–79 | Negotiate or run a bounded pilot. Require at least 3 on fulfilment, continuity, state readiness and workflow before live deployment. |
| All gates pass; below 70 | Redesign or shortlist another arrangement. |
| Any later gate deterioration | Suspend reliance on the previous approval and initiate the agreed clinical/legal continuity process. |
A score above 80 is not an instruction to purchase. The committee must still reject an arrangement that breaches a predeclared affordability, exposure or other mandatory limit.
Explore the table row by row
A working view of the research
0
- Meaning
- No usable evidence, or demonstrated inability to meet the criterion
Sources cited on this page
See the section’s source register for the research context.
Section sources →